J Korean Orthop Assoc.  2016 Jun;51(3):246-254. 10.4055/jkoa.2016.51.3.246.

A Study on the Current Status of Medical Lawsuits in Orthopedics in Korea

• Lee W
• Lee MJ
• Kim YM
• Woo CM
• Kim SY
• Kim YS

• KMID: 2308586
• DOI: http://doi.org/10.4055/jkoa.2016.51.3.246

Abstract

PURPOSE
Through the analysis of orthopedics lawsuit rulings, the purpose of this study is to understand the current trends of medical lawsuits in orthopedics in Korea.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
An analysis of medical lawsuits in orthopedics was conducted. As the study method, a quantitative analysis was performed on 341 cases.
RESULTS
The average period of lawsuits, from the occurrence of the medical accident to end of the ruling, took an average of 4.22 years. The most frequent procedure that was the main cause of the medical accidents was surgery, at 46.3%. When surgery is the main procedure that caused the medical accidents, the result of examining the types of surgeries showed that spine surgery had the highest percentage. For the outcome of the accident, the highest number of cases resulted in disability and for the final court outcome, 40.5% ruled partially in favor of the plaintiff (the patient) with acknowledgement of only the damage incurred due to medical error of the total sum claimed, and dismissal of the claim made by the plaintiff (patient) accounted for 34.3%; 26.1% of cases develop infection. For the amount of claim for damage, the average amount of claim was 181,998,036 won; in the judgement amount, the average amount of judgement was 58,897,161 won.
CONCLUSION
The most frequent procedure in orthopedics was surgery and spine surgery comprised a large proportion of these surgeries. Future studies to determine root causes of medical accidents should be conducted to reduce medical lawsuits and to plan against the repeating of medical accidents.

Keyword

medical lawsuit; medical lawsuit in orthopedics

MeSH Terms

Korea*
Medical Errors
Methods
Orthopedics*
Spine

Reference

1. Top 20 Highly Frequent Diseases Submitted to Surgery (2006) [Internet]. Seoul: Statistics Korea;2007. cited 2014 Jan 6. Available from: http://kosis.kr/gen_etl/start.jsp?orgId=350&tblId=DT_35004_A01&conn_path=I2&path=보건•사회•복지-보건-건강보험-건강보험주요수술통계-다빈도수술질환별순위20위-다빈도수술질환별순위20위(2006년).

2. Top 20 Highly Frequent Diseases Submitted to Surgery (2007)[Internet]. Seoul: Statistics Korea;2008. cited 2014 Jan 6. Available from: http://kosis.kr/gen_etl/start.jsp?orgId=350&tblId=DT_35004_A03&conn_path=I2&path=보건•사회•복지-보건-건강보험-건강보험주요수술통계-다빈도수술질환별순위20위-다빈도수술질환별순위20위(2007년).

3. Top 20 Highly Frequent Diseases Submitted to Surgery (2008)[Internet]. Seoul: Statistics Korea;2009. cited 2014 Jan 6. Available from: http://kosis.kr/gen_etl/start.jsp?orgId=350&tblId=DT_35004_A03&conn_path=I2&path=보건•사회•복지-보건-건강보험-건강보험주요수술통계-다빈도수술질환별순위20위-다빈도수술질환별순위20위(2008년).

4. Top 20 Highly Frequent Diseases Submitted to Surgery (2009)[Internet]. Seoul: Statistics Korea;2010. cited 2014 Jan 6. Available from: http://kosis.kr/gen_etl/start.jsp?orgId=350&tblId=DT_35004_A05&conn_path=I2&path=보건•사회•복지-보건-건강보험-건강보험주요수술통계-다빈도수술질환별순위20위-다빈도수술질환별순위20위(2009년).

5. Top 20 Highly Frequent Diseases Submitted to Surgery (2010)[Internet]. Seoul: Statistics Korea;2011. cited 2014 Jan 6. Available from: http://kosis.kr/gen_etl/start.jsp?orgId=350&tblId=DT_35004_A06&conn_path=I2&path=보건•사회•복지-보건-건강보험-건강보험주요수술통계-다빈도수술질환별순위20위-다빈도수술질환별순위20위(2010년).

6. Top 20 Highly Frequent Diseases Submitted to Surgery (2011)[Internet]. Seoul: Statistics Korea;2012. cited 2014 Jan 6. Available from: http://kosis.kr/gen_etl/start.jsp?orgId=350&tblId=DT_35004_A07&conn_path=I2&path=보건•사회•복지-보건-건강보험-건강보험주요수술통계-다빈도수술질환별순위20위-다빈도수술질환별순위20위(2011년).

7. Park JH. It seems disaster is approaching for specialist hospital market that is in excess supply [Internet]. Seoul: The Kyunghyang Shinmun;2013. 02. 26. cited 2014 Jan 6. Available from: http://news.khan.co.kr/kh_news/khan_art_view.html?artid=201302261535532&code=900303.

8. Korea Consumer Agency. Annual report on consumer redress and casebook 2009. Seoul: Korea Consumer Agency;2010. p. 331.

9. Korea Consumer Agency. Annual report on consumer redress and casebook 2010. Seoul: Korea Consumer Agency;2011. p. 273.

10. Korea Consumer Agency. Annual report on consumer redress and casebook 2011. Seoul: Korea Consumer Agency;2012. p. 285.

11. Min TW. 'Medical dispute adjustment application' The proportion of seniors 60s is the highest [Internet]. Seoul: The Kukmin Daily;2013. 02. 26. cited 2014 Jan 6. Available from: http://news.kukinews.com/article/view.asp?page=1&gCode=kmi&arcid=0006926070&cp=nv.

12. Kim SY. Research on the costs associated with medical accidents to improve the relative value of risk. Final report. Seoul: Health Insurance Review & Assessment Service;2012. p. 310.

13. Min HY. A study on the significantly influential factors of malpractice suit [thesis]. Seoul: Yonsei University;1997. 112.

14. Kim JO. Research on a development measure for a medical accident prevention system. Final report. Seoul: Korea Medical Dispute Mediation and Arbitration Agency;2012. p. 285.

15. Kim CY. The judical precedent analysis about medical malpractice of medicine field [thesis]. Seoul: Yonsei University;2000. 76.

16. Shin EH. A study for analysis of the current status of medical disputes and the characteristics by medical department: centered on the data of 2006 Korea Consumer Agency [thesis]. Seoul: Yonsei University;2007. 101.

17. Park JT, Park YK. Manaul of clinical orthopedics. 2nd ed. Seoul: Hyunmoonsa;2007. p. 651.

18. Lee MJ. Building the patient safety system through analyses on causes of medical accidents: based on the patient safety Databank [thesis]. Seoul: Yonsei University;2012. 144.

19. Kim SH, Park HW. A study on preventive strategies of medical accident through analyzing medical disputes-centered on foreign patients. Korean J Med Law. 2012; 20:95–120.