J Korean Neurosurg Soc.  2021 Jan;64(1):4-12. 10.3340/jkns.2020.0105.

Is the Spinal Instability Neoplastic Score Accurate and Reliable in Predicting Vertebral Compression Fractures for Spinal Metastasis? A Systematic Review and Qualitative Analysis

• Lee CH
• Hong JT
• Lee SH
• Yi S
• Sohn MJ
• Kim SH
• Chung CK
• Korean Spine Oncology Research Society

• KMID: 2510754
• DOI: http://doi.org/10.3340/jkns.2020.0105

Abstract

Spinal metastases can present with varying degrees of mechanical instability. The Spinal Instability Neoplastic Score (SINS) was developed as a tool to assess spinal neoplastic-related instability while helping to guide referrals among oncology specialists. Some previous papers suggested that the SINS was accurate and reliable, while others disagreed with this opinion. We performed a systematic review regarding the SINS to evaluate its accuracy and precision in predicting vertebral compression fractures (VCFs). The 21 included studies investigated a total of 2118 patients. Thirteen studies dealt with the accuracy of SINS to predict postradiotherapy VCFs, and eight dealt with the precision. Among 13 studies, 11 agreed that the SINS categories showed statistically significant accuracy in predicting VCF. Among eight studies, body collapse was effective for predicting VCFs in six studies, and alignment and bone lesion in two studies. Location has no statistical significance in predicting VCFs in any of the eight studies. The precision of SINS categories was substantial to excellent in six of eight studies. Among the six components of the SINS, the majority of the included studies reported that location showed near perfect agreement; body collapse, alignment, and posterolateral involvement showed moderate agreement; and bone lesion showed fair agreement. Bone lesion showed significant accuracy in predicting VCFs in half of eight studies, but displayed fair reliability in five of seven studies. Although location was indicated as having near perfect reliability, the component showed no accuracy for predicting VCFs in any of the studies and deleting or modifying the item needs to be considered. The SINS system may be accurate and reliable in predicting the occurrence of postradiotherapy VCFs for spinal metastasis. Some components seem to be substantially weak and need to be revised.

Keyword

Spine; Metastasis; Spinal neoplastic instability score; Fractures, Compression; Radiotherapy

Figure

• 

  Fig. 1. Flow diagram outlining the process for selecting relevant studies.

Reference

References

1. Aiba H, Kimura T, Yamagami T, Watanabe N, Sakurai H, Kimura H, et al. Prediction of skeletal-related events in patients with non-small cell lung cancer. Support Care Cancer. 24:3361–3367. 2016.

2. Arana E, Kovacs FM, Royuela A, Asenjo B, Pérez-Ramírez Ú, Zamora J, et al. Spine Instability Neoplastic Score: agreement across different medical and surgical specialties. Spine J. 16:591–599. 2016.

3. Bollen L, Groenen K, Pondaag W, van Rijswijk CSP, Fiocco M, Van der Linden YM, et al. Clinical evaluation of the spinal instability neoplastic score in patients treated with radiotherapy for symptomatic spinal bone metastases. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 42:E956–E962. 2017.

4. Campos M, Urrutia J, Zamora T, Román J, Canessa V, Borghero Y, et al. The spine instability neoplastic score: an independent reliability and reproducibility analysis. Spine J. 14:1466–1469. 2014.

5. Chang SY, Ha JH, Seo SG, Chang BS, Lee CK, Kim H. Prognosis of single spinal metastatic tumors: predictive value of the spinal instability neoplastic score system for spinal adverse events. Asian Spine J. 12:919–926. 2018.

6. Cunha MV, Al-Omair A, Atenafu EG, Masucci GL, Letourneau D, Korol R, et al. Vertebral compression fracture (VCF) after spine stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT): analysis of predictive factors. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 84:e343–e349. 2012.

7. Fisher CG, DiPaola CP, Ryken TC, Bilsky MH, Shaffrey CI, Berven SH, et al. A novel classification system for spinal instability in neoplastic disease: an evidence-based approach and expert consensus from the Spine Oncology Study Group. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 35:E1221–E1229. 2010.

8. Fisher CG, Schouten R, Versteeg AL, Boriani S, Varga PP, Rhines LD, et al. Reliability of the Spinal Instability Neoplastic Score (SINS) among radiation oncologists: an assessment of instability secondary to spinal metastases. Radiat Oncol. 9:69. 2014.

9. Fisher CG, Versteeg AL, Schouten R, Boriani S, Varga PP, Rhines LD, et al. Reliability of the spinal instability neoplastic scale among radiologists: an assessment of instability secondary to spinal metastases. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 203:869–874. 2014.

10. Fourney DR, Frangou EM, Ryken TC, Dipaola CP, Shaffrey CI, Berven SH, et al. Spinal instability neoplastic score: an analysis of reliability and validity from the spine oncology study group. J Clin Oncol. 29:3072–3077. 2011.

11. Fox S, Spiess M, Hnenny L, Fourney DR. Spinal Instability neoplastic score (SINS): reliability among spine fellows and resident physicians in orthopedic surgery and neurosurgery. Global Spine J. 7:744–748. 2017.

12. Germano IM, Carai A, Pawha P, Blacksburg S, Lo YC, Green S. Clinical outcome of vertebral compression fracture after single fraction spine radiosurgery for spinal metastases. Clin Exp Metastasis. 33:143–149. 2016.

13. Huisman M, van der Velden JM, van Vulpen M, van den Bosch MA, Chow E, Öner FC, et al. Spinal instability as defined by the spinal instability neoplastic score is associated with radiotherapy failure in metastatic spinal disease. Spine J. 14:2835–2840. 2014.

14. Kumar N, Ravikumar N, Tan JYH, Akbary K, Patel RS, Kannan R. Current status of the use of salvaged blood in metastatic spine tumour surgery. Neurospine. 15:206–215. 2018.

15. Lam TC, Uno H, Krishnan M, Lutz S, Groff M, Cheney M, et al. Adverse outcomes after palliative radiation therapy for uncomplicated spine metastases: role of spinal instability and single-fraction radiation therapy. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 93:373–381. 2015.

16. Landis JR, Koch GG. The measurement of observer agreement for categorical data. Biometrics. 33:159–174. 1977.

17. Lee CH, Chung CK, Jahng TA, Kim KJ, Kim CH, Hyun SJ, et al. Which one is a valuable surrogate for predicting survival between Tomita and Tokuhashi scores in patients with spinal metastases? A meta-analysis for diagnostic test accuracy and individual participant data analysis. J Neurooncol. 123:267–275. 2015.

18. Lee CH, Kwon JW, Lee J, Hyun SJ, Kim KJ, Jahng TA, et al. Direct decompressive surgery followed by radiotherapy versus radiotherapy alone for metastatic epidural spinal cord compression: a meta-analysis. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 39:E587–E592. 2014.

19. Lee J, Rhee WJ, Chang JS, Chang SK, Koom WS. Evaluation of predictive factors of vertebral compression fracture after conventional palliative radiotherapy for spinal metastasis from colorectal cancer. J Neurosurg Spine. 28:333–340. 2018.

20. Lee SH, Tatsui CE, Ghia AJ, Amini B, Li J, Zavarella SM, et al. Can the spinal instability neoplastic score prior to spinal radiosurgery predict compression fractures following stereotactic spinal radiosurgery for metastatic spinal tumor?: a post hoc analysis of prospective phase II single-institution trials. J Neurooncol. 126:509–517. 2016.

21. Malhotra K, Lui DF, Butler JS, Selvadurai S, Molloy S. Successful nonsurgical treatment for highly unstable fracture subluxation of the spine secondary to myeloma. Spine J. 16:e547–e551. 2016.

22. Massaad E, Fatima N, Hadzipasic M, Alvarez-Breckenridge C, Shankar GM, Shin JH. Predictive analytics in spine oncology research: first steps, limitations, and future directions. Neurospine. 16:669–677. 2019.

23. Matsumoto Y, Shinoto M, Endo M, Setsu N, Iida K, Fukushi JI, et al. Evaluation of risk factors for vertebral compression fracture after carbon-ion radiotherapy for primary spinal and paraspinal sarcoma. Biomed Res Int. 2017:9467402. 2017.

24. Murtaza H, Sullivan CW. Classifications in brief: the spinal instability neoplastic score. Clin Orthop Relat Res. 477:2798–2803. 2019.

25. Park JH, Lee DG, Hwang J, Lee SH, Eoh W, Kim ES. The impact of surgical treatment on survival in patients with cervical spine metastases. Neurospine. 15:144–153. 2018.

26. Patchell RA, Tibbs PA, Regine WF, Payne R, Saris S, Kryscio RJ, et al. Direct decompressive surgical resection in the treatment of spinal cord compression caused by metastatic cancer: a randomised trial. Lancet. 366:643–648. 2005.

27. Ropper AE, Huang KT, Ho AL, Wong JM, Nalbach SV, Chi JH. Intraoperative cerebrospinal fluid leak in extradural spinal tumor surgery. Neurospine. 15:338–347. 2018.

28. Sahgal A, Atenafu EG, Chao S, Al-Omair A, Boehling N, Balagamwala EH, et al. Vertebral compression fracture after spine stereotactic body radiotherapy: a multi-institutional analysis with a focus on radiation dose and the spinal instability neoplastic score. J Clin Oncol. 31:3426–3431. 2013.

29. Shi DD, Hertan LM, Lam TC, Skamene S, Chi JH, Groff M, et al. Assessing the utility of the spinal instability neoplastic score (SINS) to predict fracture after conventional radiation therapy (RT) for spinal metastases. Pract Radiat Oncol. 8:e285–e294. 2018.

30. Sung SH, Chang UK. Evaluation of risk factors for vertebral compression fracture after stereotactic radiosurgery in spinal tumor patients. Korean J Spine. 11:103–108. 2014.

31. Teixeira WG, Coutinho PR, Marchese LD, Narazaki DK, Cristante AF, Teixeira MJ, et al. Interobserver agreement for the spine instability neoplastic score varies according to the experience of the evaluator. Clinics (Sao Paulo). 68:213–218. 2013.

32. Thibault I, Al-Omair A, Masucci GL, Masson-Côté L, Lochray F, Korol R, et al. Spine stereotactic body radiotherapy for renal cell cancer spinal metastases: analysis of outcomes and risk of vertebral compression fracture. J Neurosurg Spine. 21:711–718. 2014.

33. Thibault I, Atenafu EG, Chang E, Chao S, Ameen AO, Zhou S, et al. Risk of vertebral compression fracture specific to osteolytic renal cell carcinoma spinal metastases after stereotactic body radiotherapy: a multiinstitutional study. J Radiosurg SBRT. 3:297–305. 2015.

34. Uei H, Tokuhashi Y, Maseda M, Nakahashi M, Sawada H, Matsumoto K, et al. Clinical results of minimally invasive spine stabilization for the management of metastatic spinal tumors based on the epidural spinal cord compression scale. Biomed Res Int. 2018:1258706. 2018.

35. Versteeg AL, van der Velden JM, Verkooijen HM, van Vulpen M, Oner FC, Fisher CG, et al. The effect of introducing the spinal instability neoplastic score in routine clinical practice for patients with spinal metastases. Oncologist. 21:95–101. 2016.

36. Versteeg AL, Verlaan JJ, Sahgal A, Mendel E, Quraishi NA, Fourney DR, et al. The spinal instability neoplastic score: impact on oncologic decision-making. Spine (Phila Pa 1976). 41 Suppl 20:S231–S237. 2016.

37. Virk MS, Han JE, Reiner AS, McLaughlin LA, Sciubba DM, Lis E, et al. Frequency of symptomatic vertebral body compression fractures requiring intervention following single-fraction stereotactic radiosurgery for spinal metastases. Neurosurg Focus. 42:E8. 2017.

38. Weber MH, Burch S, Buckley J, Schmidt MH, Fehlings MG, Vrionis FD, et al. Instability and impending instability of the thoracolumbar spine in patients with spinal metastases: a systematic review. Int J Oncol. 38:5–12. 2011.