J Korean Neuropsychiatr Assoc.  2017 Feb;56(1):1-9. 10.4306/jknpa.2017.56.1.1.

Critical Review on Amendment Bill of Mental Health Act

• Park JI
• Park HJ

• KMID: 2379373
• DOI: http://doi.org/10.4306/jknpa.2017.56.1.1

Abstract

The Korean Mental Health Act, enacted in 1995, was entirely amended 20 years later and the amendment was passed by the National Assembly plenary session on May 19. 2015. The amended Mental Health Act reflects the recent rapid changes in the mental health environment and contributes one more step toward securing human rights for people with mental illness. However, after review of some major issues, it is doubtful whether there was sufficient discussion on the national mental health policy and whether a national consensus was obtained. This paper describes some problems within the amended Act and discusses several ways to improve the Act. Patients' autonomy and medical paternalism are typical major concerns in the field of medical ethics. Especially for patients with mental illness, it is difficult to maintain a balance between those two concerns because there is often an inability to assign responsibility for those concerns. Therefore, a revised Act should take into account these two concerns. When creating subordinate legislation ahead of the enactment of the amendments on May 30, 2016, establishment of a more reasonable and efficient system is expected ; if there has been sufficient discussion with related organizations and professionals and sufficient consideration of the realities of various medical fields. Such expectations should improve public mental health welfare.

Keyword

Mental Health Act; Admission by person responsible for protective custody; Involuntary admission; Self-determination

MeSH Terms

Consensus
Ethics, Medical
Human Rights
Humans
Mental Health*
Paternalism

Reference

1. Park MS. Major issues of mental health law revision: social welfare meaning and role. In : Proceedings of the Korea Academy of Mental Health and Social Work 2016 Annual Spring Conference; 2016 May 20; Seoul, Korea. Seoul: The Korea Academy of Mental Health Social and Work Academic Publications;2016. p. 87–90.

2. Knpa.or.kr [homepage on the Internet]. A statement of opinion for the revision of “Mental health promotion and welfare service support” Act. 2016. 05. 16. cited 2016 May 20. Available from: http://www.knpa.or.kr.

3. Suh T. History of the Korean Mental Health Act. J Korean Neuropsychiatr Assoc. 2010; 49:144–148.

4. Lee JW, Son DS. Theory of mental health and social welfare. Seoul: Seohyunsa;2007. p. 4–50.

5. Shin KC. The legal status of mental illness: exclusion to integration [dissertation]. Seoul: Seoul National University;2012.

6. Ccourt.go.kr [homepage on the Internet]. Constitutional Court of Korea. 2014HearnGa9 decision, 2016. 9. 29. cited 2016 Oct 30. A vailable from: http://search.ccourt.go.kr/ths/pr/ths_pr0101_P1.do?seq=0&cname=&eventNum=41196&eventNo=2014%ED%97%8C%EA%B0%809&pubFlag=0&cId=010200&selectFont=.

7. Lee JY. Today 25 years ago: arson disaster following refusal of admission to night club. The Money Today. 2016. 10. 17.

8. Choi JA. The news then: reckless driving leading to 23 victims in Yoido Square. KBS News. 2016. 10–19.

9. Kim CJ. Necessity of revision and amendment direction of the Mental Health Law. Seoul: The National Assembly Notification Magazine, National Assembly;2007. p. 8–22.

10. Kim JK, Lee JY, Park HJ. Current problems and improvement of Mental Health Law. Inha Law Rev. 2013; 4:13–36.

11. Suh TW. Mental health policy and law in Korea. Health Welf Policy Forum. 2007; 123:42–56.

12. Moon SD. A theory of mental health and social welfare. study on the revision of the Mental Health Act in 2007. J Police Act. 2007; 5:94–116.

13. Law.go.kr [homepage on the Internet]. Mental Health Act. cited 2016 Nov 4. Available from: http://www.law.go.kr/lsInfoP.do?lsiSeq=59049&ancYd=20030529&ancNo=06893&efYd=20040530&nwJoYnInfo=N&efGubun=Y&chrClsCd=010202#0000.

14. Lee DM. A study on the enforcement hospitalization in the Mental Health Law. Korean J Criminol. 2001; 13:137–163.

15. National Human Rights Commission of Korea. Survey on human rights of persons with mental illness. Seoul: National Human Rights Commission of Korea;2009.

16. Shin KC. Ideology through the ideals and reality of Mental Health Law. In : Proceedings of the Korea Academy of Mental Health and Social Work 2016 Annual Spring Conference; 2016 May 20; Seoul, Korea. Seoul: The Korea Academy of Mental Health Social and Work Academic Publications;2016. p. 15–32.

17. The National Mental Health Commission. The national report on the results of preliminary survey on the state of mental health in Korea. Seoul: The National Mental Health Commission;2015.

18. Lim BH. The problems and reform of the Mental Health Act. Seoul: National Assembly Legislation Report;2007.

19. Shin KC. Problem analysis and improvement strategy for involuntary admission in Mental Health Act: focusing on the restoration of personal subject turned into reification. Seoul Law Rev. 2016; 22:637–639.

20. Kim SW, Lee MW. The meaning of the constitutional unconformity decision and the legislative improvement task. Seoul: The National Assembly Research Service: Issues and Point;2016.

21. Kim SK. Promotion of national mental health and enhancement of human rights and welfare for mentally ill people. Seoul: The National Assembly Notification Magazine, National Assembly;2016. p. 1–2.

22. Yeom HG. Major issues in ‘Mental Health Law’ revision. In : Proceedings of the Korea Academy of Mental Health and Social Work 2016 Annual Spring Conference; 2016 May 20; Seoul, Korea. Seoul: The Korea Academy of Mental Health Social and Work Academic Publications;2016. p. 35–59.

23. Shin KC. A normative study on the concept of people with mental illness. Korean Lawyers Assoc. 2010; 59:35–76.

24. Shin EJ. The problem and the solution of involuntary admission of Mental Illness. Korean J Med Law. 2009; 17:21–48.

25. Hong SM. Case studies and establishment of advanced models of countries to improve human rights for people with mental illness. Seoul: National Human Rights Commission of Korea;2009.