J Korean Med Assoc.  2014 Feb;57(2):104-113.

Historico-philosophical consideration on the social role of French doctor: medical anthropology of Pierre-Jean-Georges Cabanis (1757-1808) and the French code of medical deontology

• Han HJ

Abstract

Doctor's task cannot be limited to medical practice and research. As a citizen of society, and above all as a professional, doctors should not evade their social responsibilities. This idea was systematically developed and widely diffused throughout Europe by Pierre-Jean-Georges Cabanis (1757-1808). He was not only a doctor, but also a philosopher and a politician who lived at the time of the French Revolution. His philosophy on the nature of medicine and the social role of the doctor is conceptualized in his idea of medical anthropology (science de l'homme, anthropologie). In order to understand why the social role of the doctor was particularly emphasized in and around France, Cabanis' medical anthropology should be analyzed in depth. His medical anthropology is composed of three major domains: physiology, ethics, and analysis of ideologies. The following ideas of his medical anthropology can be identified in the current articles of the French code of medical deontology. 1) Health and disease being a social problem, a social solution should be sought (1.6, 1.7, 1.10, 2.37, 2.44, 2.50); 2) Medical practice is in principle not a commercial service for profit, but rather a public service supported by the government's power (1.12, 1.19, 1.21, 2.55, 3.57, 3.67); 3) Doctors should maintain their professional autonomy by establishing and observing the principles of self-regulation (1.1, 1.5, 1.31, 2.50, 5.109, 5.110). Referring to the historical experience of French doctors, the Korean medical community should also enter into a broad and fundamental reflection on the nature of medicine and the social role of the doctor.

Keyword

France; Pierre-Jean-Georges Cabanis; Social role; Medical anthropology; Code of medical deontology

MeSH Terms

Anthropology, Medical*
Ethics
Europe
France
French Revolution
Philosophy
Physiology
Professional Autonomy
Social Problems
Social Responsibility

Figure

• 

  Figure 1 Pierre-Jean-Georges Cabanis' medical anthropology and its 3 major domains.

Reference

1. Guillois A. The salon of Madame Helvetius, Cabanis, and the ideologues. Paris: Calmann Levy;1894.

2. Staum MS. Cabanis: enlightenment and medical philosophy in the French Revolution. Princeton: Princeton University Press;1980.

3. Role A, Boulet L. Georges Cabanis: the doctor of Brumaire. Paris: Editions Fernand Lanore;1994.

4. Han HJ. Pierre-Jean-Georges Cabanis (1757-1808) and philosophy of clinical medicine. Philos Med. 2013; 16:57–85.

5. Han HJ. Pierre-Jean-Georges Cabanis and the demand of the empiricism in medicine. In : Fagot-Largeault A, editor. The emergence of the scientific medicine. Paris: Editions Materiologiques;2011. p. 55–76.

6. Compare Your Country. Life expectancy at birth [Internet]. place unknown: Compare Your Country;cited 2014 Jan 17. Available from: http://www.compareyourcountry.org/health/index.php.

7. Chevreul K, Durand-Zaleski I, Bahrami S, Hernandez-Quevedo C, Mladovsky P. France: health system review 2010. Health Syst Transit. 2010; 12:1–291.

8. Cabanis PJ. Overview on revolutions and reform of medicine. In : Lehec C, Cazeneuve J, editors. Philosophical works of Cabanis. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France;1956. Vol. 2:p. 70–221.

9. Barthez PJ. New elements of the science of man. 3rd ed. Paris: Germer Bailliere;1858.

10. Han HJ. The vitalism of Paul-Joseph Barthez (1734-1806). Korean J Med Hist. 2010; 19:157–188.

11. Cabanis PJ. Reports on the physical and the moral of man. In : Lehec C, Cazeneuve J, editors. Philosophical works of Cabanis. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France;1956. Vol. 1:p. 126–357.

12. Platner E. Anthropology for physicians and the worldwise. Leipzig: Dyck;1772.

13. Kant I. Anthropology from a pragmatic point of view. Konigsberg: Friedr Nicolovius;1798.

14. Cabanis PJ. Statements at the Council of Five Hundred. In : Lehec C, Cazeneuve J, editors. Philosophical works of Cabanis. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France;1956. Vol. 2:p. 408.

15. Cabanis PJ. Observations on hospitals. In : Lehec C, Cazeneuve J, editors. Philosophical works of Cabanis. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France;1956. Vol. 1:p. 23–26.

16. Cabanis PJ. The degree of certainty of medicine. In : Lehec C, Cazeneuve J, editors. Philosophical works of Cabanis. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France;1956. Vol. 1:p. 68–71.

17. Foucault M. Spaces and classes. In : Foucault M, editor. The birth of the clinic. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France;1963. p. 19.

18. Cabanis PJ. Some principles and some views on public assistances. In : Lehec C, Cazeneuve J, editors. Philosophical works of Cabanis. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France;1956. Vol. 2:p. 1–63.

19. Canguilhem G. What is a scientific ideology?. In : Canguilhem G, editor. Ideology and rationality in the history of the life sciences. 2nd ed. Paris: Vrin;1993. p. 35.

20. Foucault M. The lesson of the hospitals. In : Foucault M, editor. The birth of the clinic. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France;1963. p. 63–86.

21. Foucault M. A political consciousness. In : Foucault M, editor. The birth of the clinic. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France;1963. p. 35.

22. Canguilhem G. The epistemological status of medicine. In : Canguilhem G, editor. Studies of history and philosophy of science. 7th ed. Paris: Vrin;1994. p. 421–422.

23. Canguilhem G. Health: vulgar concept and philosophical question. In : Canguilhem G, editor. Writings on medicine. Paris: Seuil;2002. p. 61.