J Korean Med Assoc.  2011 Nov;54(11):1137-1145.

Development of medical professionalism in South Korea

• Ahn D

Abstract

Consensus on an accurate translation of 'professionalism' for the Korean language has not been reached. Therefore, it is not surprising that medical professionalism as a concept is in a stage of infancy in Korea. The rudimentary nature of collective professionalism in East Asia can be attributed to the historical and sociocultural differences found in Western countries. In this study, the author identifies and describes the facilitating and hindering factors for the development of the concept of collective professionalism in Korean medicine. The collective nature of professionalism could not naturally develop in an authoritarian and hierarchical social environment such as Korea. Furthermore, the recent trend of commercialization and industrialization of medicine as a major business enterprise has also contributed to the medical community's lack of knowledge on this issue. Nevertheless, the global trend reappraisal of professionalism has shed light on theoretical discourse on professionalism in Korean medicine. It is essential for Korea, as one of the developed nations, to explore not only the historical trajectory of the current Japanese-style Western medicine, but also to understand the sociocultural background of the original Western medicine with knowledge of the professionalism that developed subsequently in the West. If Korean medicine is to rise above its colonial roots and guarantee its prosperity and survival as a profession, it has no choice but to put effort into the establishment of medical professionalism.

Keyword

Collective professionalism; History; Authenticity

MeSH Terms

Commerce
Consensus
Developed Countries
Far East
Korea
Light
Republic of Korea
Social Environment

Reference

1. Kang YS. The concepts and discussions about medical professionalism in Korea. Korean J Med Ethics. 2010. 13:255–261.

2. Kim S, Hur Y. How are we going to evaluate medical professionalism? Korean J Med Educ. 2005. 17:1–14.

3. Professionalism and doctors' engagement towards society [Internet]. 2003. cited 2011 Oct 14. Quebec: Medical Council of Quebec;Available from: http://www.csbe.gouv.qc.ca/fileadmin/www/Archives/ConseilMedical/Avis/2003_01_av_fr.pdf.

4. Kang SI. Professional medical ethics in the cultural context of Korea. Korean J Med Ethics Educ. 2004. 7:151–166.

5. Cabanis PJ. Lehec C, Cazeneuve J, editors. A look at the revolution and reform of medicine. Philosophical works of Cabanis. 1956. Paris: PUF;68–71.

6. Inai K. History of medical education in Japan with special reference to informed consent. Proceeding 26th Annual Conference of Korean Society of Medical Education. 2010. 2010 Jun 19; Jeju. Korea. Seoul: Korean Society of Medical Education.

7. Kim YI. The Meiji Restoration and profit hospital. The Hankyoreh Newspaper. 2011. 08. 27. Opinion section.

8. Ahn D. Authenticity of Korean medical education. Authenticity of Korean medical education. 2010. 2010 Jun 17; Jeju. Korea. Seoul: Korean Society of Medical Education.

9. MacIntyre A. After virtue: a study in moral theory. 1984. 2nd ed. Notre Dame: Notre Dame University Press.

10. Cheong YS. Medical professionalism and clinical autonomy in Korea. Korean J Med Ethics Educ. 2004. 7:141–150.

11. A new type of NHS hospital. NHS Foundation Trusts: ten key points [Internet]. cited 2011 Oct 14. London: Department of Health (UK);Available from: http://www.dh.gov.uk/en/Publicationsandstatistics/Publications/PublicationsPolicyAndGuidance/Browsable/DH_5691128.

12. Lee J. State control of medicine through legislation and revision of the medical law: licensed and unlicensed medical practices in the 1950s-60s. Korean J Med Hist. 2010. 19:385–432.