A study on the change of implant stability using resonance frequency analysis

Park, Chan Jin; Kim, Yung Soo; Kim, Chang Whe; Cho, Lee Ra; Yi, Yang Jin

Abstract

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM: Resonance frequency analysis (RFA) has been increasingly served as a non-invasive and objective method for clinical monitoring of implant stability. Many clinical studies must be required for standardized baseline data using RFA. PURPOSE: This study was performed to evaluate RFA value changes in two stage surgery group and one stage surgery group in patients. MATERIAL AND METHOD: Forty-seven mandibles in consecutively implant installed patients were selected for this study and 141 fixtures were installed. Ninety-three fixtures were double threaded, machined surface design (Bra.nemark. MK III, Nobel Biocare AB, Go teborg, Sweden) and 48 fixtures were root form, threaded, HA-coated surface one (Replace(TM), Steri-Oss/Nobel Biocare AB, USA). Among those, each 10 fixture was installed in one stage group patients. ISQ values were measured using Osstell(TM) (Integration Diagnostics Ltd. Sweden) during fixture installation, at healing abutment connection and in the loading period for two stage surgery group patients and during at each 4, 6, 8, 10, 12 week and in the loading phase for one stage surgery group patients and evaluated the changes according to the time and fixture type. RESULTS: In two stage surgery group, mean and SD of ISQ values of machined surface implants were 76.85 +/- 3.74, 75.76 +/- 5.04, 75.73 +/- 4.41 and those of HA-coated surface implant were 75.05 +/- 6.23, 77.58 +/- 5.23, 78.32 +/- 4.29 during fixtures installation, at healing abutment connection and in the loading period, respectively. In one-stage surgery group, the ISQ values of machined surface and HA-coated surface implants decreased until 4 or 6 week and maintained at plateau for 1-3 week and increased to the loading period. CONCLUSIONS: Machined and HA-coated surface implants showed minimal ISQ changes with time if they were installed at the sites showing at least intact cortical plate and good bone qualities. And HA-coated implants had a tendency to show somewhat increased ISQ values with time.