A clinical study of patients with acute liver injury caused by herbal medication in Gyeongju area

Chun, Woo Jung; Yoon, Byung Gu; Kim, Nam Il; Lee, Goo; Yang, Chang Heon; Lee, Chang Woo; Suh, Jeong Ill

Abstract

BACKGROUND: The prevalence of acute viral liver injury is decreasing, but drug induced liver injury by herbal medicine and health foods is on an increasing trend after introduction of vaccination. Nevertheless, there is no consensus of diagnostic method and causality assessment for acute liver injury. Therefore, the cause, clinical features, prevalence and pattern of acute liver injury caused by herbal medicine and health foods in Gyeongju area were analyzed. Moreover, Council for International Organization of Medical Science (CIOMS) scale and Maria and Victorino (MandV) scale, clinical scales for causality assessment in hepatotoxicity were compared.
METHODS
78 patients in whom there was definite evidence of taking medicine and there was one more increase of over 2N (upper limit of the normal range) in alanine aminotransferase (ALT) or total bilirubin (TB) or alkaline phosphatase (ALP) and self-remitted after drug stop were selected excluding patients with previous liver disease history and history of alcohol, metabolic liver disease and hapatobiliary disease and viral, autoimmune, unknown origin hepatitis among 150 patients of admission due to acute liver injury, from April 1997 to March 2001. Each case was investigated retrospectively about taken medicine, the pattern of liver injury, recovery period after drug stop, history of alcohol, other hepatobiliary disease, pregnancy, recent hypotension, rechallenge and viral markers of hepatitis, aspartate aminotransferase (AST), ALT, TB, ALP. Also, herbal medicine and western medicine groups were compared and consistency with CIOMS scale and MandV scale were investigated.
RESULTS
For four years, among 150 cases, drug-induced liver injury were 78 cases (52.0%), occurred the highest prevalence. In taken medicine, western medicine were 39 cases (50.0%), herbal medicine and health foods were 39 cases (50.0%), too. Among those cases, herbal medication were 23 cases (58.9%), pellet 5 cases (12.8%), In-jin-ssuk 3 cases (7.7%), deer extract 3 cases (7.7%), kitosan 2 cases (5%) and pumpkin extract, carp, plant roots was 1 case (2.5%) respectively. In the pattern of liver injury, hepatocellular liver injury were 48 cases (61.5%), occurred the highest prevalence. Between CIOMS and MandV scale, best correlation were only 2 cases (2.6%), therefore, their agreement was very low.
CONCLUSION
The prevalence of drug induced liver injury is on an increasing trend in Gyeongju area and acute liver injury caused by herbal medicine and health foods had very high incidence was ascertained. Therefore, we should attend to indiscreet use of herbal medicine and health foods and should give a warning to our society. And a new clinical scale suitable for characteristic of our country that had high prevalence of liver injury caused by herbal medicine and health food is needed.