Outcomes of Bypass Surgery Versus Endovascular Therapy for TASC II C and D Femoro-Popliteal Lesions in Patients with Chronic Limb Ischemia

Shin, Sung Hwan; Kwon, Se Hwan; Cho, Jin Hyun; Ahn, Hyung Joon; Oh, Joo Hyung; Park, Ho Chul

Abstract

PURPOSE
We wanted to define the appropriate treatment modalities for Trans-Atlantic Inter-Society Consensus (TASC) II C and D femoro-popliteal lesions. So we compared the primary patency rate and several clinical factors between percutaneous balloon angioplasty with or without stenting (PTA/S) and bypass surgery (BP).
METHODS
We reviewed the medical records of patients who underwent BP or PTA/S for TASC II C (BP-C, PTA/S-C) and D (BP-D, PTA/S-D) femoro-popliteal lesions from March 2001 to May 2009. We analyzed the primary and secondary patency rates, and the major limb salvage rates.
RESULTS
Eighty two limbs in 74 patients (mean age: 68.7+/-10.2 years, males: 82.9%) were treated (PTA/S-C: 18, PTA/S-D 19: BP-C 12, BP-D 33). The mean follow-up duration was 30.0+/-19.0 months. The twenty four month primary patency rates was 82.4% for PTA/S-C and 73.3% for BP-C (P=0.876), and 45.3% for PTA/S-D and 66.6% for BP-D (P=0.034). The twenty four month secondary patency rates were 88.2% for PTA/S-C and 73.3% for BP-C (P=0.669), and 54.7% for PTA/S-D and 73.3% for BP-D (P=0.077). The twenty four month major limb salvage rates were 100.0% for PTA/S-C and 75.0% for BP-C (P=0.030) but there were no statistical differences between the TASC II D groups (P=0.377).
CONCLUSION
Bypass surgery is a preferred initial therapeutic option for TASC II D femoro-popliteal lesions. However, several clinical factors must be carefully considered when selecting the primary treatment modality for TASC II C lesions.